An overview of the controversial practice of commercial whaling

Subsistence whaling is the taking of a limited number of whales by certain indigenous peoples for their own use. Unlike member states who may be concerned with retaliation, NGOs are politically independent and, as a result, more aggressive enforcers of international norms.

History of Whaling

Closely related to this issue is the necessity for improved scientific research conducted by an international body. And some species were killed by poachers and fishermen that were looking to lower their competition for hunting fish or because the dolphins were interfering with their fishing equipment.

Proposed Solution Increased concern for the global environment creates the necessity for effective international agreements focused on the preservation of common resources that transcend territorial boundaries.

The quota was reduced to zero in that year due to sustainability concerns.

Te Piringa - Faculty of Law

The primary aim of the study was to deepen the understanding of fish —whale interactions. Whaling in the Philippines Whaling in the Philippines has been illegal since under Fisheries Administrative Order The whalers then brought the captured whales to the ship and butchered and processed them into oil.

The agency should be instructed to certify only non-lethal research programs focused on the comprehensive study of marine mammals and their ecosystem and food supply. Recent progress in the field of international environmental law may shed some light on the current whaling controversy by providing alternatives to strengthen conservation efforts.

The organization should also encourage research aimed at uncovering the relationship between whale populations and environmental degradation such as marine pollution and depletion of the ozone layer. The new conservation-minded states began to advocate greater restrictions on whaling, citing new scientific studies demonstrating the advanced intellectual capacity of whales.

In Soviet society, whaling was perceived to be a glamorous and well-paid job. Representatives of these groups claim that whaling represents an integral part of their cultures and provides an important dietary resource.

Still, devoid of an effective enforcement mechanism, the Commission was forced to incorporate the country's reported statistics into their own figures, thus destroying the reliability of their calculations.

Debate: Whaling

We were asked to collect more data. They are killing whales for profit, the research ploy is nothing but a gross loop-hole to continue something that is illegal. For centuries, whales provided valuable natural resources in the form of food and fuel to the world's population, and the whaling industry contributed substantially to the economic wealth of countries such as Norway, England, The Netherlands, the U.

By the sixteenth century, the Basques' whaling techniques had spread across the Atlantic. The quota was reduced to zero in that year due to sustainability concerns. Following this evidence, the U. Similarly, the Convention on the International Trade in Endangered Species CITES has implemented a ban on international trade of whale products, but the three whaling countries have registered exemptions - which essentially allows the countries to trade among each other and other non-CITES members.

In a few cases, threat of unilateral sanctions may result in a token effort toward correcting the offense. First, an "opt out" provision in the treaty makes it virtually impossible for the Commission to curtail the actions of member nations who oppose a specific regulation.

Sincethe ICRW has been the only multilateral international agreement focused solely on the regulation of whale stocks. Individual states should be encouraged to continue the protest against Japan's whaling activities without incurring GATT-related liability.

There was a problem providing the content you requested

As a result, Japan refuses to concede on the whaling issue for fear it might adversely affect the country's tradition of exploration and exploitation of the seas. However, under the terms of the convention the Icelandic government issued permits for a scientific catch.

This would save some 5, whales from being slaughtered. The controversial Japanese whale hunt in Antarctic waters is an example of modern research whaling.

While the proposal has received strong opposition from both proponents and opponents of whaling, the BBC reports that the initiative is "almost certain" to be presented to the International Whaling Commission IWC by 22 April - the deadline for submissions to be voted on at the Commission's annual meeting, set to kick off on 21 June in Agadir, Morocco.

These nations, along with the global community, called for the IWC to reform its policies and to incorporate newly discovered scientific data regarding whales in its proposed regulations.

Simon Lyster, International Wildlife Law 17 Bryde's whales can yield as much meat in the Japanese market as five minke whales and adult sperm whales, the largest of the toothed whales, can reach lengths of sixty feet and weigh up to forty-five tons.

Catches have fluctuated between animals in to in Japan claims that whale stocks for some species are sufficiently large to sustain commercial hunting and blame filibustering by the anti-whaling side for the continuation of scientific whaling.

Subsistence whaling from an older era had never captured whales on such a scale. Given the large jurisdictional area under the IWC's control, independent monitoring is critical to identify and prevent violations that no state can easily uncover.

However, Iceland appears to be resolute against agreeing to quotas and, more importantly, a clause stipulating that any whales caught cannot be exported.Some whaling continues for research purposes, mostly by Japan, which has been widely criticised for taking hundreds more whales than can be justified by the needs of scientific inquiry.

Recently Japan and Norway have led demands from some countries for the lifting of the ban and the resumption of some whaling under regulation. Hunting for Whales: Outdated Practice Essay words - 6 pages Whales have been around on Earth for many years.

One thing that originated due to the population of the speices is whaling. Whaling is the act of hunting for whales whether in the need for food, for scientific research, or for commercial reasons. While most people think about whaling in recent years the history of whaling dates back to at least 3, B.C.

with some researchers obtain possible evidence of this practice extending as far back as 6, B.C. Commercial whaling is a controversial whaling practice that exploits whale products for trade and profit. Recently, Japan, Norway and Iceland are the major contributors of commercial whaling and deeply support any other whaling activities (Joanne ).

Japan wants to restructure IWC to make it easier for it to start commercial whaling again

Captain Watson’s words could not be truer when it comes to the issues surrounding international commercial whaling.

[tags: commercial whaling, conservation, whaling industry] Overview of the Whaling of the Makah People Whaling is a very dangerous and gruesome practice in which whales are killed and harvested for parts.

Init rejoined the IWC with accession documents that included a controversial reservation that it claimed exempted it from the commercial whaling moratorium.

It resumed so-called “scientific whaling” in and commercial whaling (including of fin whales) under its reservation in

History of Whaling Download
An overview of the controversial practice of commercial whaling
Rated 3/5 based on 93 review